Choosing The Right Dog Breed: Matching People To Dogs

Choosing the Right Dog

Need help choosing the right dog breed?  It can get a little overwhelming, so we’re breaking down the decision making process into manageable steps.  Feel free to skip any step that doesn’t seem to fit you and read more about those that resonate with you.  

A graphic showing the factors involved in choosing a dog breed

We broke the process down into two steps (with many sub steps)

  1. Learning about yourself and your needs and wants.  Part One
  2. Learning about dog breeds and what you can expect.  Part Two

In Part One of this two part series, we examined your needs and wants, your strengths and weaknesses,  and your motivations. 

In Part Two, we’ll look at different dog characteristics such as age, size, gender, appearance and breed status.   If you haven’t read part one, I suggest you go back and read through it so that this part will make more sense to you.

As a quick review, I asked you to answer the following questions:

Choosing the Right Dog Breed Based on Your Lifestyle, Needs and Wants

  • Why do you want a dog?
  • Have you ever owned a dog before?
  • What is your energy level?
  • What is your current financial situation?
  • How much free time do you have for a dog?
  • What is work schedule:  How much time will the dog be alone during the day?
  • How do you rate your physical strength?
  • How well do you enjoy a challenge?
  • How much does the dog’s appearance play into your view of the ideal dog?

Choosing the Right Dog Breed Based on Living Arrangements

  • Do you live alone?
  • Any allergies to pet dander in your household?
  • What type of home do you live in?
  • How particular are you about your home’s interior?
  • What type of climate do you live in?
  • Do You have other pets in the household?

According to the ASPCA, “Approximately 7.6 million companion animals enter animal shelters nationwide every year. Of those, approximately 3.9 million are dogs and 3.4 million are cats.”

Of the dogs entering shelters, approximately 35% are adopted, 31% are euthanized and 26% of dogs who came in as strays are returned to their owner.

Now, let’s look at some dog characteristics that might make a difference to you.  

Some of these factors will be more important to you than others. 

Age considerations when Choosing the Right Dog Breed

Choosing the right breed dog
Puppy or Adult

Age is usually a factor in the initial stages of deciding on a dog.  

Age also plays a part on where you are likely to find your new canine friend.  

While there are many developmental stages in the course of a dog’s life, for convenience, I’ve broken their lifespan down to four:  

Puppy, Adolescent and Young Adult, Middle Age, Senior.

Have you considered the age of the dog you will get?

Read more on Age


Choosing the right breed dog
Gender Decisions

Gender is very important some people especially if they have had dogs before.  If female dogs seemed perfect before, why take a chance on a boy?

Some folks don’t have a preference. 

Some people have a strong opinion.  Which gender is really best for you? 

Or, is there no difference.

Read more on Gender


Color shouldn’t matter but it does.  Some breeds have many different colors from which to choose and others come in only one color.  If you hate white dogs, then you not likely to choose a Maltese, Pyrenean Mountain Dog or Kuvasz.  You’d better love black if your ideal breed is a Schipperke.

Hair / Coat Appearance and Texture

Long and Luxurious or Short and Sassy

Dog breeds come in several textures and lengths

Textures:  Curly,    Smooth    Wire,     Corded

Lengths:  Hairless,  Short,   Medium,  Long

Single coat,  Double Coat

Coats that Shed year round,     seasonal shedders,    low shedding dogs

Read about Coat Characteristics

Breed Status

People often think about purebred dogs when it comes to make a breed choice, but cross breeds or hybrids and mutts make equally wonderful pets.  

Like age, the status of the breed you choose will often dictate where you begin your search.  Breeders normally breed one or maybe two purebred dogs and some also produce hybrids, popularly known as designer dogs. 

Shelters and humane societies will be the obvious place to look for mutts.  Why research breeds, you might ask if you want a mutt? Knowing what types of breeds went into your mutt will help you understand the dog and assist with training. 

Choosing the Right Dog Breed For You

You’ve pondered many questions, but there are a few more to consider and just a little more homework.

Before visiting that breeder that has new puppies, consider do just a little bit more research.

  • Research the Breed’s History
  • Find out whether your breed is most appropriate for novice owners or experienced ones.
  • Learn about the Breed’s Health Issues
  • Understand the Breed’s Temperament, Energy Levels.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *